I Ching Reading: Meng (Youthful Ignorance) changing to Sun (Decrease)

慎

Read the cautions carefully.

In opening the mind of someone ignorant, punish when punishment is due; after punishing, ease off a little and see how he does afterward. Keep punishing without ever letting go, and you will be left with regrets. It is so in teaching people, and the same in handling anything.

PrimaryMeng (Youthful Ignorance)
ResultingSun (Decrease)

Governing text · Meng: Six at the beginning

Text發蒙,利用刑人,用說桎梏,以往吝。Opening up the ignorant. It is favorable to use punishment, and then to take off the shackles. To go on that way brings humiliation.

In plain wordsIn opening the mind of someone ignorant, punish when punishment is due; after punishing, ease off a little and see how he does afterward. Keep punishing without ever letting go, and you will be left with regrets. It is so in teaching people, and the same in handling anything.

Zhu Xi’s original note
説吐活反桎音質梏古毒反○以隂居下䝉之甚也占者遇此當𤼵其䝉然𤼵之之道當痛懲而暫舍之以觀其後若遂往而不舍則致羞吝矣戒占者當如是也
Primary context
Things go through. It is not I who go seeking the ignorant child; it is the child who comes seeking me. The first time he asks in earnest, I tell him. To ask again and again is to take it lightly, and one who takes it lightly is not told. It is favorable to stay true.
The key
Only one line is changing: Six at the beginning. The answer is in that line. Keep the distinct conditions and cautions in this passage separate.
Resulting context
A reference, not a guaranteed future: Cut back what should be cut back. As long as it comes from sincerity, it is great good fortune, no blame; you can hold to it, and it is favorable to act. What do you use to show what is in your heart? Two bowls of plain food can serve as the offering — it does not matter if the gift is slight.
Governing guidance
In opening the mind of someone ignorant, punish when punishment is due; after punishing, ease off a little and see how he does afterward. Keep punishing without ever letting go, and you will be left with regrets. It is so in teaching people, and the same in handling anything.
Show more details

Which text applies

One changing line: read that line of the primary hexagram.

Your six throws, bottom to top: 1: 6 yin (changing) · 2: 7 yang · 3: 8 yin · 4: 8 yin · 5: 8 yin · 6: 7 yang

The seven rules for changing lines →

Line position

Not in its proper place · not answered by the fourth line

First place: the beginning of the matter. Low position, little power. Begin carefully.

Verdict words in the text

  • 利 favorable: a course of action that helps, under the stated condition
  • 吝 humiliation: a small, lingering difficulty that comes from not correcting course

Nuclear hexagram · Fu (Return)

The worst is over, and the turn has come.

The nuclear hexagram is formed from the four inner lines. It shows what is going on inside the situation.

Full texts

Meng (Youthful Ignorance): judgment and all six lines →

Sun (Decrease): judgment and all six lines →

View the text and explanation for Meng (Youthful Ignorance)

Ask the I Ching

Use this reading to think things through. You decide what to do.