I Ching Reading: Dui (Joy) changing to Jie (Limitation)

慎

Read the cautions carefully.

You weigh two kinds of pleasure back and forth and your heart cannot settle. If you can cleanly hold to the right one and turn away from the wrong one, there will be happiness.

PrimaryDui (Joy)
ResultingJie (Limitation)

Governing text · Dui: Nine in the fourth place

Text商兌未寧,介疾有喜。Deliberating over joy, not yet at peace. Holding firm against the sickness, there is happiness.

In plain wordsYou weigh two kinds of pleasure back and forth and your heart cannot settle. If you can cleanly hold to the right one and turn away from the wrong one, there will be happiness.

Zhu Xi’s original note
四上承九五之中正而下比六三之柔邪故不能決而商度所説未能有定然質本陽剛故能介然守正而疾惡柔邪也如此則有喜矣象占如此為戒深矣
Primary context
Things go through, and it is favorable to stay true. Making people glad is a good thing, but you must not use improper means to please them.
The key
Only one line is changing: Nine in the fourth place. The answer is in that line. Keep the distinct conditions and cautions in this passage separate.
Resulting context
A reference, not a guaranteed future: Things go through. But when restraint reaches the point of making people suffer, it cannot be kept up forever as the right way.
Governing guidance
You weigh two kinds of pleasure back and forth and your heart cannot settle. If you can cleanly hold to the right one and turn away from the wrong one, there will be happiness.
Show more details

Which text applies

One changing line: read that line of the primary hexagram.

Your six throws, bottom to top: 1: 7 yang · 2: 7 yang · 3: 8 yin · 4: 9 yang (changing) · 5: 7 yang · 6: 8 yin

The seven rules for changing lines →

Line position

Not in its proper place · not answered by the first line

Fourth place: next to the ruler, a place of caution. Serve those above with care.

Nuclear hexagram · Jiaren (The Family)

First put the affairs of the household (your own inner circle) in order.

The nuclear hexagram is formed from the four inner lines. It shows what is going on inside the situation.

Full texts

Dui (Joy): judgment and all six lines →

Jie (Limitation): judgment and all six lines →

View the text and explanation for Dui (Joy)

Ask the I Ching

Use this reading to think things through. You decide what to do.