I Ching Reading: Dun (Retreat) changing to Pi (Standstill)

慎

Read the cautions carefully.

Attachment obstructs retreat: illness and danger. “Good fortune in keeping servants and concubines” is a narrowly specified ancient category, not a general promise that staying to care for others is fortunate. Beware entanglement in larger responsibilities.

PrimaryDun (Retreat)
ResultingPi (Standstill)

Governing text · Dun: Nine in the third place

Text係遯,有疾厲。畜臣妾吉。A retreat held back by ties. There is sickness and danger. Keeping servants and maids brings good fortune.

In plain wordsAttachment obstructs retreat: illness and danger. “Good fortune in keeping servants and concubines” is a narrowly specified ancient category, not a general promise that staying to care for others is fortunate. Beware entanglement in larger responsibilities.

Zhu Xi’s original note
畜許六反○下比二隂當遯而有所係之象有疾而危之道也然以畜臣妾則吉蓋君子之於小人惟臣妾則不必其賢而可畜耳故其占如此
Primary context
When it is time to withdraw, withdraw; once you step back, the way actually opens. The side that is gaining ground should also stay true, and not use its momentum to press others.
The key
Only one line is changing: Nine in the third place. The answer is in that line. Keep the distinct conditions and cautions in this passage separate.
Resulting context
A reference, not a guaranteed future: Blocked and shut off; this is not the kind of world people ought to have. Even keeping to the right course brings the noble one little advantage; the great has gone and the small has come.
Governing guidance
Attachment obstructs retreat: illness and danger. “Good fortune in keeping servants and concubines” is a narrowly specified ancient category, not a general promise that staying to care for others is fortunate. Beware entanglement in larger responsibilities.
Show more details

Which text applies

One changing line: read that line of the primary hexagram.

Your six throws, bottom to top: 1: 8 yin · 2: 8 yin · 3: 9 yang (changing) · 4: 7 yang · 5: 7 yang · 6: 7 yang

The seven rules for changing lines →

Line position

In its proper place · not answered by the top line

Third place: the top of the lower trigram, a place of risk. A moment of transition. Be on guard.

Verdict words in the text

  • 吉 good fortune: the matter turns out well
  • 厲 danger: a real risk, survivable if you stay alert

Nuclear hexagram · Gou (Encounter)

A person or a matter you run into unexpectedly; do not get deeply involved lightly.

The nuclear hexagram is formed from the four inner lines. It shows what is going on inside the situation.

Full texts

Dun (Retreat): judgment and all six lines →

Pi (Standstill): judgment and all six lines →

View the text and explanation for Dun (Retreat)

Ask the I Ching

Use this reading to think things through. You decide what to do.