I Ching Reading: Song (Conflict) changing to Pi (Standstill)

参

Read the meaning in context.

You cannot win this case — the other side is stronger than you. Pull back, keep out of the way, stay in your own small place and live frugally, and no disaster will come.

PrimarySong (Conflict)
ResultingPi (Standstill)

Governing text · Song: Nine in the second place

Text不克訟,歸而逋,其邑人三百戶,无眚。Unable to win the dispute, he goes home and slips away. His town is one of three hundred households. No harm comes.

In plain wordsYou cannot win this case — the other side is stronger than you. Pull back, keep out of the way, stay in your own small place and live frugally, and no disaster will come.

Zhu Xi’s original note
逋補吳反眚生領反○九二陽剛為險之主本欲訟者也然以剛居柔得下之中而上應九五陽剛居尊勢不可敵故其象占如此邑人三百户邑之小者言自處卑約以免災患占者如是則无眚矣
Primary context
You are in the right but blocked, and you need to keep a sense of caution in your heart. Settle partway: good fortune. Insist on fighting to the end: misfortune. It is good to find someone fair and weighty to judge the matter; it is not good to take big risks at this time.
The key
Only one line is changing: Nine in the second place. The answer is in that line. This summary does not turn no blame, no regret, or an image into a promise of good fortune.
Resulting context
A reference, not a guaranteed future: Blocked and shut off; this is not the kind of world people ought to have. Even keeping to the right course brings the noble one little advantage; the great has gone and the small has come.
Governing guidance
You cannot win this case — the other side is stronger than you. Pull back, keep out of the way, stay in your own small place and live frugally, and no disaster will come.
Show more details

Which text applies

One changing line: read that line of the primary hexagram.

Your six throws, bottom to top: 1: 8 yin · 2: 9 yang (changing) · 3: 8 yin · 4: 7 yang · 5: 7 yang · 6: 7 yang

The seven rules for changing lines →

Line position

Not in its proper place · central · not answered by the fifth line

Second place: the center of the lower trigram, a place of praise. Stay centered and yielding.

Verdict words in the text

  • 无咎 no blame: no fault attaches, often because a mistake is corrected in time

Nuclear hexagram · Jiaren (The Family)

First put the affairs of the household (your own inner circle) in order.

The nuclear hexagram is formed from the four inner lines. It shows what is going on inside the situation.

Full texts

Song (Conflict): judgment and all six lines →

Pi (Standstill): judgment and all six lines →

View the text and explanation for Song (Conflict)

Ask the I Ching

Use this reading to think things through. You decide what to do.