Lin, six in the third placeHexagram 19, line 3 · Lin (Approach) · changing to 11

The line

Text甘臨,无攸利。既憂之,无咎。Sweet approach. Nothing is favorable. Once one worries over it, no blame.

In plain wordsDealing with people through nice words and a pleasant face does no good at all. But if you are already worried about it and willing to change, there is no blame.

Zhu Xi’s original note
隂柔不中正而居下之上為以甘說臨人之象其占固无所利然能憂而改之則无咎也勉人遷善為教深矣

View this line and its explanation →

The Image commentary on this line

甘臨,位不當也。既憂之,咎不長也。

"Sweet approach": the place is not proper. "Once one worries over it", the blame does not last.

The small Image commentary is the earliest explanation of the line texts. It usually explains a line from its position: where it stands, whether it holds the center, and which line answers it.

Verdict

慎Caution / mixed conditions. Keep the distinct conditions and cautions in this passage separate.

  • 无咎 no blame: no fault attaches, often because a mistake is corrected in time
  • 无攸利 nothing is favorable: no course of action helps right now

How to read good fortune, misfortune, regret, humiliation and no blame →

Asking about work, love or money

Work
Leading people and getting things done by saying nice things and pleasing everyone does no good at all. It is good that you have noticed something is wrong. Switch quickly to doing things for real, and the problem will not last long.
Love
Getting by on sweet talk and coaxing the other person along won't win you real feeling; it only grows emptier. Once you see it, change: say fewer nice things and do more real ones. There is still time.
Money
Using sweet talk, connections and pleasant promises to bring in business or borrow money does you no good. When you see it is not right, stop, keep your words honest and your numbers real, and you will not go wrong.

This is how to read it when this is the only changing line. With several changing lines, first see which text governs; for the hexagram as a whole, see Lin.

Line position

A yin line in a yang place: it is not in its proper place. Its partner is the top line, which is also yin, so there is no answer from it.

Third place: the top of the lower trigram, a place of risk. A moment of transition. Be on guard.

Proper place, center and correspondence explained →

When you get this line

If this is the only changing line in your cast (three inscribed sides, old yin), this line is your answer. The primary hexagram is Lin (Approach); when this line changes it becomes Tai (Peace): hexagram 19 changing to 11.

Which text to read with several changing lines →

Resulting hexagram · Tai (Peace)

A good time when above and below are in touch and everything runs smoothly.

See the full reading for this cast →